Roaring dynamics in rutting male red deer Cervus elaphus from five Russian populations

Rusin I.Yu., Volodin I.A., Sitnikova E.F., Litvinov M.N., Andronova R.S., Volodina E.V.

P. 44-58

In Russia, current populations of Cervus elaphus sensu lato represent a mix of fragmented remnants of ancestral red deer naturally radiated from their center of origin in Middle Asia and populations, either re-stored by people at places where the native red deer are extinct or kept for agricultural production. Male rutting roaring activity represents an important part of red deer reproduction but there are no methods for unified evaluation of roaring dynamics. This study proposes the criteria for subdividing the entire rut period to phases (start, active, fading), applicable irrespectively to differences in population geographical area, animal density, subspecies or absolute values of call number per hour. With this approach, we estimate stag rutting roaring activity on hourly basis in five populations of red deer belonging to three subspecies by using two spaced automated recording devices per population, recording roars for 5 min/hour, 24 h/day, for 52–60 days of rutting period. Two spaced recorders per population provided similar data on rut dynamics, although absolute values of call number per hour were different. In four of the five study populations, rut period covered approximately the same calendar dates, from the last days of August until the last ten days of October. The mean roaring activity over a rut period differed strongly between populations (from 4– 15 calls/h to 319–377 calls/h). Effects of time of day on roaring activity differed between rut phases. The possible reasons of this variability are discussed.DOI: 10.15298/rusjtheriol.20.1.06

• Balieiro F. & Monticelli P.F. 2019. Evidence of individual discrimination in the maned wolf long-distance extended-bark // Behavioural Processes. Vol.158. P.219–227.
• Bocci A., Telford M. & Laiolo P. 2013. Determinants of the acoustic behaviour of red deer during breeding in a wild alpine population, and implications for species survey // Ethology, Ecology & Evolution. Vol.25. P.52–69.
• Bowyer T.R. & Kitchen D.W. 1987. Sex and age-class differences in vocalization of Roosevelt elk during rut // American Midland Naturalist. Vol.118. P.225–235.
• Briefer E., Vannoni E. & McElligott A.G. 2010. Quality prevails over identity in the sexually selected vocalisations of an ageing mammal // BMC Biology. Vol.8. No.35. P.1–15.
• Clutton-Brock T.H. & Albon S.D. 1979. The roaring of red deer and the evolution of honest advertising // Behaviour. Vol.69. P.145–170.
• Cohen J. 1992. A power primer // Psychological Bulletin. Vol.112. No.1. P.155–159.
• de Knijff P., Denkers F., van Swelm N.D. & Kuiper M. 2001. Genetic affinities within the herring gull Larus argentatus assemblage revealed by AFLP genotyping // Journal of Molecular Evolution. Vol.52. No.1. P.85–93.
• Della Libera M., Passilongo D. & Reby D. 2015. The acoustics of male rutting roars in the endangered population of Mesola red deer Cervus elaphus italicus // Mammalian Biology. Vol.80. P.395–400.
• Desjonquères C., Rybak F., Ulloa J.S., Kempf A., Hen A.B. & Sueur J. 2020. Monitoring the acoustic activity of an aquatic insect population in relation to temperature, vegetation and noise // Freshwater Biology. Vol.65. No.1. P.107–116.
• Doohan B., Fuller S., Parsons S. & Peterson E.E. 2019. The sound of management: Acoustic monitoring for agricultural industries // Ecological Indicators. Vol.96. P.739–746.
• Douhard M., Bonenfant C., Gaillard J.-M., Hamann J.-L. & Jacques M.G. 2013. Roaring counts are not suitable for the monitoring of red deer Cervus elaphus population abundance // Wildlife Biology. Vol.19. P.94–101.
• Enari H., Enari H., Okuda K., Yoshita M., Kuno T. & Okuda K. 2017. Feasibility assessment of active and passive acoustic monitoring of sika deer populations // Ecological Indicators. Vol.79. P.155–162.
• Farina A. 2019. Ecoacoustics: a quantitative approach to investigate the ecological role of environmental sounds // Mathematics. Vol.7. No.1. P.21.
• Fedosenko A.K. 1980. [The Maral (Ecology, Behaviour, Management)]. Alma-Ata: Nauka. 200 p. [in Russian].
• Feighny J.A., Williamson K.E. & Clarke J.A. 2006. North American elk bugle vocalizations: male and female bugle call structure and context // Journal of Mammalogy. Vol.87. P.1072–1077.
• Ferreira L.M., Oliveira E.G., Lopes L.C., Brito M.R., Baumgarten J., Rodrigues F.H. & Sousa-Lima R.S. 2018. What do insects, anurans, birds, and mammals have to say about soundscape indices in a tropical savanna // Journal of Ecoacoustics. Vol.2. PVH6YZ.
• Frey R., Volodin I.A., Volodina E.V., Carranza J. & Torres-Porras J. 2012. Vocal anatomy, tongue protrusion behaviour and the acoustics of rutting roars in free-ranging Iberian red deer stags (Cervus elaphus hispanicus) // Journal of Anatomy. Vol.220. P.271–292.
• Frey R., Volodin I.A., Volodina E.V., Efremova K.O., Menges V., Portas R., Melzheimer J., Fritz G., Gerlach C. & von Dörnberg K. 2020. Savannah roars: the vocal anatomy and the impressive rutting calls of male impala (Aepyceros melampus) – highlighting the acoustic correlates of a mobile larynx // Journal of Anatomy. Vol.36. No.3. P.398–424.
• Fritz C.O., Morris P.E. & Richler J.J. 2012. Effect size estimates: current use, calculations, and interpretation // Journal of Experimental Psychology. Vol.141. No.1. P.2–18.
• García A.J., Landete-Castillejos T., Garde J.J. & Gallego L. 2002. Reproductive seasonality in female Iberian red deer (Cervus elaphus hispanicus) // Theriogenology. Vol.58. No.8. P.1553–1562.
• Gasc A., Francomano D., Dunning J.B. & Pijanowski B.C. 2017. Future directions for soundscape ecology: The importance of ornithological contributions // Auk. Vol.134. P.215–228.
• Golosova O.S., Volodin I.A., Isaeva I.L. & Volodina E.V. 2017. Effects of free-ranging, semi-captive and captive management on the acoustics of male rutting calls in Siberian wapiti Cervus elaphus sibiricus // Mammalian Research. Vol.62. P.387–396.
• Guinness F., Lincoln G.A. & Short R.V. 1971. The reproductive cycle of the female red deer, Cervus elaphus L. // Reproduction. Vol.27. No.3. P.427–438.
• Jeliazkov A., Bas Y., Kerbiriou C., Julien J.-F., Penone C. & Le Viol I. 2016. Large-scale semi-automated acoustic monitoring allows to detect temporal decline of bush-crickets // Global Ecology and Conservation. Vol.6. P.208–218.
• Kidjo N., Cargnelutti B., Charlton B.D., Wilson C. & Reby D. 2008. Vocal behaviour in the endangered Corsican deer: description and phylogenetic implications // Bioacoustics. Vol.18. P.159–181.
• Kumar V.P., Mukesh T., Rajpoot A., Joshi B.D., Nigam P., Ahmad K., Kumar D., Goyal S.P. 2017. Resolving the phylogenetic status and taxonomic relationships of the hangul (Cervus elaphus hanglu) in the family Cervidae // Mitochondrial DNA. Part A: DNA Mapping, Sequencing and Analysis. Vol.28. No.6. P.835–842.
• Kuznetsova M.V., Danilkin A.A. & Kholodova M.V. 2012. Phylogeography of red deer (Cervus elaphus): analysis of mtDNA cytochrome b polymorphism // Biology Bulletin. Vol.39. No.4. P.323–330.
• Kuznetsova M.V., Surjev V.I., Kolomejtsev S.G., Likhatskij J.P., Sipko T.P. & Kholodova M.V. 2013. [Genetic status of red deer (Cervus elaphus) inhabiting Rostov region and some other regions of European part of Russia: results of a mitochondrial DNA investigation] // Vestnik Okhotovedeniya. Vol.10. No.1. P.53–65 [in Russian].
• Letopis prirody 2017. [Number of mammals] // Letopis Prirody of Nature Reserve “Bolshekhekhtsirsky”. Vol.48. P.180–184 [in Russian].
• Liebers D., de Knijff P. & Helbig A.J. 2004. The herring gull complex is not a ring species // Proceedings Biological Science B. Vol.271. No.1542. P.893–901.
• Likhatskij J.P., Kolomejtsev S.G., Likhatskij E.J. & Kulikov V.V. 2012. [The status of resources of European red deer and the effects of biotechnical measures on the population growth] // Kolomejtsev S.G. & Likhatskij J.P. (eds.). [Materials of the Rostov State Experimental Game Facility]. No.1. Rostov-on-Don. P.120–153 [in Russian].
• Lillis A., Caruso F., Mooney T.A., Llopiz J., Bohnenstiehl D. & Eggleston D.B. 2018. Drifting hydrophones as an ecologically meaningful approach to underwater soundscape measurement in coastal benthic habitats // Journal of Ecoacoustics. Vol.2. STBDH1.
• Litvinov M.N. 2008. [Peculiarities of ruminant fauna development at the Nature Reserve “Ussuriisky”] // [Animal and Plant World of Far East]. Vol.11. P.127–131 [in Russian].
• Ludt C.J., Schroeder W., Rottmann O. & Kuehn R. 2004. Mitochondrial DNA phylogeography of red deer (Cervus elaphus) // Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution. Vol.31. No.3. P.1064–1083.
• Lunitsin V.G. & Borisov N.P. 2012. [Deer Management for Velvet Antlers Production in Russia]. Barnaul: VNIIPO. 1000 p. [in Russian].
• Mahmut H., Masuda R., Onuma M., Takahashi M., Nagata J., Suzuki M. & Ohtaishi N. 2002. Molecular phylogeography of the red deer (Cervus elaphus) populations in Xinjiang of China: comparison with other Asian, European, and North American populations // Zoological Science. Vol.19. No.4. P.485–495.
• Matrosova V.A., Ivanova A.D., Volodina E.V., Volodin I.A., Alexandrov D.Y., Sibiryakova O.V. & Ermakov O.A. 2019. Phylogenetic relationship and variation of alarm call traits of populations of red-cheeked ground squirrels (Spermophilus erythrogenys sensu lato) suggest taxonomic delineation // Integrative Zoology. Vol.14. P.341–353.
• Matrosova V.A., Rusin M.Y., Volodina E.V., Proyavka S.V., Savinetskaya L.E., Shekarova O.N., Rashevska H.V. & Volodin I.A. 2016. Genetic and alarm call diversity across scattered populations of speckled ground squirrels (Spermophilus suslicus) // Mammalian Biology. Vol.81. P.255–265.
• McComb K., Packer C. & Pusey A. 1994. Roaring and numerical assessment in contests between groups of female lions, Panthera leo // Animal Behaviour. Vol.47. P.379–387.
• McPherson F.J. & Chenoweth P.J. 2012. Mammalian sexual dimorphism // Animal Reproduction Science. Vol.131. P.109–122.
• Nikol
• Passilongo D., Reby D., Carranza J. & Apollonio M. 2013. Roaring high and low: composition and possible functions of the Iberian stag’s vocal repertoire // PLoS ONE. Vol.8. No.5. e63841.
• Pepin D., Cargnelutti B., Gonzalez G., Joachim J. & Reby D. 2001. Diurnal and seasonal variations of roaring activity of farmed red deer stags // Applied Animal Behavior Science. Vol.74. No.3. P.233–239.
• Pérez-González J., Barbosa A.M., Carranza J. & Torres-Porras J. 2010. Relative effect of food supplementation and natural resources on female red deer distribution in a Mediterranean ecosystem // Journal of Wildlife Management. Vol.74. No.8. P.1701–1708.
• Pshenichnikova O.S., Klenova A.V., Sorokin P.A., Konyukhov N.B., Andreev A.V., Kharitonov S.P., Zubakin V.A., Artukhin Y.B. & Schacter C.R. 2017. Population differentiation in whiskered auklets Aethia pygmaea: do diurnal and nocturnal colonies differ in genetics, morphometry and acoustics? // Journal of Avian Biology. Vol.48. P.1047–1061.
• Pshenichnikova O.S., Klenova A.V., Sorokin P.A., Zubakin V.A., Konyukhov N.B., Kharitonov S.P. & Artukhin Y.B. 2015. The crested auklet, Aethia cristatella (Alcidae, Charadriiformes), does not vary geographically in genetics, morphology or vocalizations // Marine Biology. Vol.162. P.1329–1342.
• Reby D., Andre-Obrecht R., Galinier A., Farinas G. & Cargnelutti B. 2006. Cepstral coefficients and hidden Markov models reveal idiosyncratic voice characteristics in red deer (Cervus elaphus) stags // The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. Vol.120. No.6. P.4080–4089.
• Reby D. & McComb K. 2003. Anatomical constraints generate honesty: acoustic cues to age and weight in the roars of red deer stags // Animal Behaviour. Vol.65. P.519–530.
• Rusin I.Y., Volodin I.A., Andronova R.S. & Volodina E.V. 2019. Passive acoustic monitoring of roaring activity in male wapiti Cervus elaphus xanthopygus at Far East of Russia: effects of recording site, temperature and time of day // Nature Conservation Research. Vol.4. No.3. P.34–44.
• Sánchez-Prieto C.B., Carranza J. & Pulido F.J. 2004. Reproductive behavior in female Iberian red deer: effects of aggregation and dispersion of food // Journal of Mammalogy. Vol.85. No.4. P.761–767.
• Sibiryakova O.V., Volodin I.A. & Volodina E.V. 2018. Advertising individual identity by mother and adolescent contact calls in Siberian wapiti Cervus elaphus sibiricus // Ethology. Vol.124. No.10. P.733–742.
• Sitnikova E.F. & Mishta A.V. 2006. [Fauna of mammals of the Bryansk region: list of species, distribution, population number] // Fedorov J.P. (ed.). [Studying and Conservation of Biological Diversity of the Bryansk Region. Materials on Management of Red Book of the Bryansk Region]. No.2. Trubchevsk: Kirillitsa. P.107–150 [in Russian].
• Sitnikova E.F. & Mishta A.V. 2008. [Mammals of the Reserve “Bryansk Forest”] // Fedorov J.P. & Sitnikova E.F. (eds.). [Fauna of Vertebrate Animals of the Reserve “Bryansk Forest” (Birds, Mammals)]. Bryansk: Desyatochka. P.50–85 [in Russian].
• Smith B.L. 1994. Out-of-season births of elk calves in Wyoming // Prairie Naturalist. Vol.26. No.2. P.131–136.
• Struhsaker T.T. 1968. The behavior of the elk (Cervus canadensis) during the rut // Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie. Vol.24. P.80–114.
• Sugai L.S.M., Silva T.S.F., Ribeiro J.W.J.R. & Llusia D. 2019. Terrestrial passive acoustic monitoring: review and perspectives // BioScience. Vol.69. No.1. P.15–25.
• Towsey M., Znidersic E., Broken-Brow J., Indraswari K., Watson D.M., Phillips Y., Truskinger A. & Roe P. 2018. Long-duration, false-colour spectrograms for detecting species in large audio datasets // Journal of Ecoacoustics. Vol.2. IUSWUI.
• Trepet S.A. & Eskina T.G. 2017. Modern dynamics of the red deer (Cervus elaphus maral) population in the Caucasian State Nature Reserve // Biology Bulletin. Vol.44. No.8. P.875–881.
• Volodin I.A., Matrosova V.A., Volodina E.V., Garcia A.J., Gallego L., Márquez R., Llusia D., Beltrán J.F. & Landete-Castillejos T. 2015a. Sex and age-class differences in calls of Iberian red deer during rut: reversed sex dimorphism of pitch and contrasting roars from farmed and wild stags // Acta Ethologica. Vol.18. P.19–29.
• Volodin I.A., Nahlik A., Tari T., Frey R. & Volodina E.V. 2019. Rutting roars in native Pannonian red deer of Southern Hungary and the evidence of acoustic divergence of male sexual vocalization between Eastern and Western European red deer (Cervus elaphus) // Mammalian Biology. Vol.94. P.54–65.
• Volodin I.A., Sibiryakova O.V. & Volodina E.V. 2016a. Sex and age-class differences in calls of Siberian wapiti Cervus elaphus sibiricus // Mammalian Biology. Vol.81. No.1. P.10–20.
• Volodin I.A., Volodina E.V., Frey R., Carranza J. & Torres-Porras J. 2013a. Spectrographic analysis points to source-filter coupling in rutting roars of Iberian red deer // Acta Ethologica. Vol.16. P.57–63.
• Volodin I.A., Volodina E.V., Frey R. & Maymanakova I.L. 2013b. Vocal activity and acoustic structure of the rutting calls of Siberian wapiti (Cervus elaphus sibiricus) and their imitation with a hunting luring instrument // Russian Journal of Theriology. Vol.12. P.99–106.
• Volodin I.A., Volodina E.V. & Golosova O.S. 2016b. Automated monitoring of vocal rutting activity in red deer (Cervus elaphus) // Russian Journal of Theriology. Vol.15. P.91–99.
• Volodin I.A., Volodina E.V., Sibiryakova O.V., Naidenko S.V., Hernandez-Blanco J.A., Litvinov M.N. & Rozhnov V.V. 2015b. Vocal activity and the acoustic structure of rutting calls in red deer in the Russian Far East // Doklady Biological Sciences. Vol.462. P.144–147.
• Yen S.-C., Shieh B.-S., Wang Y.-T. & Wang Y. 2013. Rutting vocalizations of Formosan sika deer Cervus nippon taiouanus – acoustic structure, seasonal and diurnal variations, and individuality // Zoological Science. Vol.30. No.12. P.1025–1031.