Dietary overlap of wild ungulate Cuvier’s gazelle with livestock (sheep and goats) in Djebel Messaâd Forest, Algeria

Benamor N., Bounaceur F., Aulagnier S.

P. 31-43

Studying the dietary habits of wild animals is essential for the efficient wildlife management. This paper presents the results of dietary overlap of Cuvier's gazelle (Gazella cuvieri) and two species of livestock to evaluate whether or not they compete for forage. The study was conducted from September 2016 to August 2017 in the Djebel Messaâd Forest, Algeria, using microhistological analysis. The diet of Cuvier’s gazelle and livestock maintained a high proportion of grasses, shrubs and trees. At Djebel Messaâd Forest, of the total 48 food plant species identified in fecal samples, 39 of which were found in Cuvier’s gazelle, 29 and 36 from domestic sheep and goats respectively; 20 genera occurred in the annual diets of both Cuvier’s gazelle and livestock. The principal foods were browses (N% = 52.6) for Cuvier’s gazelle, while the dominant forage species included Stipa tenacissima, Artemisia herba alba, Pistacia terebinthus, Stipa parviflora, Helianthemum sp. The food diversity was invariably high for Cuvier’s gazelle in autumn and generally decreased from winter to summer, we conclude that this gazelle exhibited a higher dietary diversity than livestock. Shared species 21 represented a higher proportion of dietary items for Cuvier’s gazelle (N% = 76.9) than for sheep (N% = 54.0). While shared 28 species, a very higher proportion of those used by Cuvier’s gazelle (N% = 91.4) than by goats (N% = 61.2). Dietary overlap indices confirmed that, livestock had very similar diets. while, both of them had moderate diet overlap with Cuvier’s gazelle.DOI: 10.15298/rusjtheriol.20.1.05

• Ait Baamrane M.A., Shehzad W., Ouhammou A., Abbad A., Naimi M., Coissac E., Taberlet P. & Znari M. 2012. Assessment of the food habits of the Moroccan Dorcas gazelle in M’Sabih Talaa, West Central Morocco, using the trnL approach // PLoS ONE. Vol.7. No.4. e35643.
• Ait Baamrane M.A., Znari M. & Bellout S. 2017. Evaluation du régime alimentaire de la Gazelle dorcas du Maroc Gazella dorcas massaesyla dans la réserve M’Sabih Talaa par analyse Microhistologique // Go-South Bulletin. Vol.14. P.125–132.
• Anthony R.G. & Smith N.S. 1974. Comparison of rumen and fecal analysis to describe deer diets // Journal of Wildlife Management. Vol.38. P.535–540.
• Arbouche Y., Arbouche H.S., Arbouche F.A. & Arbouche R. 2012. Valeur fourragère des espèces prélevées par Gazella cuvieri Ogilby, 1841 au niveau du Djebel Metlili (Algérie) // Archivos de Zootecnia. Vol.61. No.233. P.145–148.
• Baharav D. 1981. Food habits of the mountain gazelle in semi-arid habitats of eastern lower Galilée, Israel // Journal of Arid Environments. Vol.4. No.1. P.63–69.
• Bailey D.W. 1995. Daily section of feeding areas by cattle in heterogeneous environment // Applied Animal Behaviour Science. Vol.45. P.183–200.
• Bell R.H.V. 1970. The use of the herb layer by grazing ungulates in the Serengeti // Watson A. (eds.). Animal Population in Relation to Their Food Resources. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific. P.111–124.
• Belsky A.J. & Gelbard J.L. 2000. Livestock Grazing and Weed Invasions in the Arid West. Portland: Oregon Natural Desert Association. 31 p.
• Benamor N., Bounaceur F., Baha M. & Aulagnier S. 2019. First data on the seasonal diet of the vulnerable Gazella cuvieri (Mammalia: Bovidae) in the Djebel Messaâd forest, northern Algeria // Folia Zoologica. Vol.68. No.4. P.253–260.
• Beudels R.C., Devillers P., Lafontaine R.-M., Devillers Terschuren J. & Beudels M.-O. 2005. Sahelo-Saharan Antelopes: Status and Perspectives // Report on the conservation status of the six Sahelo-Saharan Antelopes, 2nd ed., UNEP/CMS Secretariat, Bonn, Switzerland. 120 p.
• Bhattacharya T., Kittur S., Sathyakumar S. & Rawat G.S. 2012. Diet overlap between wild ungulates and domestic livestock in the greater Himalaya: implications for management of grazing practices // Proceedings of the Zoological Society. Vol.65. No.1. P.11–21.
• Bounaceur F., Boualem A., Benamor N., Fellous A., Benkheira A., Bissaad F.Z. & Aulagnier S. 2016. Updated distribution and local abundance of the endangered Cuvier’s gazelle (Mammalia, Bovidae) in Algeria // Folia Zoologica. Vol.65. P.233–238.
• Bouredjli H.A. 1989. Eléments d’écoethologie de la gazelle de Cuvier: Gazella cuvieri (Ogilby, 1841) dans la réserve naturelle de Mergueb (M’Sila) et son statut en Algérie] // Thèse Ing., Institut National Agronomique El Harrach, Algérie. 88 p.
• Bryant F.C., Kothmann M.M. & Merrill L.B. 1979. Diets of sheep, Angora goats, Spanish goat and white-tailed deer under excellent range conditions // Journal of Range Management. Vol.32. P.412–417.
• Carlisle D.B. & Ghorbial L.I. 1968. Food and water requirements of Dorcas gazelle in the Sudan // Mammalia. Vol.32. No.4. P.570–576.
• Coe P.K., Johnson B.K., Kern J.W., Findholt S.L., Kie J.G. & Wisdom M.J. 2001. Responses of elk and mule deer to cattle in summer // Journal of Range Management. Vol.54. P.A51–A76.
• Cuzin F. 2003. Les Grands Mammifères du Maroc Méridional (Haut Atlas, Anti Atlas, Sahara). Distribution, Écologie et Conservation] // PhD Thesis, École Pratique des Hautes Études, Montpellier, France. 349 p.
• De Smet K. 1991. Cuvier’s gazelle in Algeria // Oryx. Vol.25. No.2. P.99–104.
• De Boer W.F. & Prins H.H.T. 1990. Large herbivores that strive mightily but eat and drink as friends // Oecologia. Vol.82. P.264–274.
• Dearden B.L., Pegau R.E. & Hansen R.M. 1975. Precision of microhistological estimates of ruminant food habits // Journal of Wildlife Management. Vol.39. No.2. P.402–407.
• Ekaya W.N. 1991. Forage preferences of livestock on a semi-and range in south-eastern Kenya // M.Sc. Thesis, University of Nairobi, Kenya. 130 p.
• El-Attoui A. 1996. Etude phytoécologique et cartographie de la végétation steppique par utilisation de télédétection (Cas, Daïra de Djebel Messaâd)] // Mém. Ing, Institut Agronomique, Université de Sétif, Algérie. 150 p.
• Field C.R. & Blankenship L.H. 1973. Nutrition and reproduction of Grant
• Fleischner T.L. 1994. Ecological costs of livestock grazing in western North America // Biological Conservation. Vol.8. P.629–644.
• Freschi P., Fascetti S., Riga F., Cosentino C., Rizzardini G. & Musto M. 2016. Diet composition of the Italian roe deer (Capreolus capreolus italicus) (Mammalia: Cervidae) from two protected areas // European Zoological Journal. Vol.84. P.34–42.
• García-Gonzalez R. 1983. Epidermis foliares de algunas especies de Festuca. Poa y Bellardiochloa en el Pirineo Occidental // Anales del Jardín Botánico de Madrid. Vol.39. No.2. P.389–404.
• Ghosh P.K., Goya S.P.I. & Bohra H.C. 1986. Habitat utilization by wild and domestic ungulates: a case study in a desert biome // Joss P.J., Lynch P.W. & Wiliams O.B. (eds.). Rangelands: a resource under siege, proceedings of the Second International Rangeland Congress, Cambridge University Press. P.549–550.
• Gordon I.J. & Illius A.W. 1988. Incisor arcade structure and diet selection in ruminants // Functional Ecology. Vol.2. P.15–22.
• Guerin H., Friot D., Mbaye N. & Richard D. 1991. Alimentation des ruminants domestiques sur pâturages naturels sahéliens et Sahélo-soudaniens. Etude méthodologique de la région du Ferlo au Sénégal. Maison Alfort, France: IEMVT. 336 p.
• Hansen R.M. & Reid L.D. 1975. Diet overlap of deer, elk, and cattle in Southern Colorado // Journal of Range Management. Vol.28. P.43–47.
• Hansen R.M., Mugambi M.M. & Bauni S.M. 1985. Diets and trophic ranking of ungulates of the northern Serengeti // Journal of Wildlife Management. Vol.49. No.3. P.823–829.
• Harris R.B. & Miller D.J. 1995. Overlap in summer habitats and diets of Tibetan Plateau ungulates // Mammalia. Vol.59. No.2. P.197–212.
• Hobbs N.T., Baker D.L. Gill R.B. 1983. Comparative nutritional ecology of montane ungulates during winter // Journal of Wildlife Management. Vol.47. No.1. P.1–16.
• Hofmann R.R. 1989. Evolutionary steps of ecophysiological adaptation and diversification of ruminants: a comparative view of their digestive system // Oecologia. Vol.78. No.4. P.443–457.
• Hofmann R.R. & Stewart D.R.M. 1972. Grazer or browser: a classification based on the stomach structure and feeding habits of East African ruminants // Mammalia. Vol.36. No.2. P.226–240.
• Holechek J.L., Vavra M. & Pieper R.D. 1982. Botanical composition determination of range herbivore diets: a review // Journal of Range Management. Vol.35. P.309–315.
• Hurtubia J., 1973. Trophic diversity measurement in sympatric predatory species // Ecology. Vol.54. P.885–890.
• IUCN. 2016. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2016: e.T8967A50186003.
• Jarman P.J. 1974. The social organisation of antelope in relation to their ecology // Behaviour. Vol.48. No.1. P.215–267.
• Kilonzo J.M., Ekaya W.N. & Kinuthia R.N. 2005. Feeding characteristics of sheep (Ovis aries) and Grant
• Kingdon J. 1997. The Kingdon Field Guide to African Mammals. San Diego: Academic Press. 496 p.
• Krebs C.J. 1999. Ecological Methodology. 2nd edn. Menlo Park: Benjamin Cummings. 620 p.
• La Morgia V. & Bassano B. 2009. Feeding habits, forage selection, and diet overlap in Alpine chamois (Rupicapra rupicapra L.) and domestic sheep // Ecological Research. Vol.24. No.5. P.1043–1050.
• Le Houérou H.N. 1980. The role of browse in the management of natural grazing lands // Le Houérou H.N. (eds.). Browse in Africa, the Current state of Knowledge. Addis Ababa: ILCA. P.329–339.
• Lerp H., Wronski T., Plath M., Schröter A. & Pfenninger M. 2013. Phylogenetic and population genetic analyses suggest a potential species boundary between mountain (Gazella gazella) and Arabian gazelles (G. arabica) in the Levant // Mammalian Biology. Vol.78. No.5. P.383–386.
• MacNally R.C. 1983. On assessing the significance of interspecific competition to guild structure // Ecology. Vol.64. No.6. P.1646–1652.
• Malechek J.C. & Leinweber C.L. 1972. Forage selectivity by goats on lightly and heavily grazed ranges // Journal of Range Management. Vol.25. P.105–111.
• Martin S.C. 1970. Determining animal consumption // Range and Wildlife Habitat Evaluation: A Research Symposium, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Miscellaneous Publication. No.1147. P.93–100.
• Martinez T.M. 2001. The feeding strategy of Spanish ibex (Capra pyrenaica) in the northern Sierra de Gredos (central Spain) // Folia Zoologica. Vol.50. P.257–270.
• Martinez T.M. 2002b. Summer feeding strategy of Spanish ibex (Capra pyrenaica) and domestic sheep (Ovis aries) in southeastern Spain // Acta Theriologica. Vol.47. P.479–490.
• Médail F. & Quézel P. 1997. Hot-spots analysis for conservation of plant biodiversity in the Mediterranean Basin // Annals of the Missouri Botanical Garden. Vol.84. No.1. P.112–127.
• Mishra C., Van Wieren S.E., Ketner P., Heitkönig I.M.A. & Prins H.H.T. 2004. Competition between domestic livestock and wild bharal Pseudois nayaur in the Indian Trans-Himalaya // Journal of Applied Ecology. Vol.41. No.2. P.344–354.
• Moleele N.M. 1998. Encroacher woody plant browses as feed for cattle. Cattle diet composition for three seasons at Olifants Drift, South-east Botswana // Journal of Arid Environments. Vol.40. P.255–268.
• Moreno E. & Espeso G. 2008. Cuviers’s gazelle, Gazella cuvieri. International Studbook. Managing and Husbandry Guidelines. Ayuntamiento de Roquetas de Mar, Almería. 140 p.
• Mphinyane W.N., Tacheba G. & Makore J. 2015. Seasonal diet preference of cattle, sheep and goats grazing on the communal grazing rangeland in the Central District of Botswana // African Journal of Agricultural Research. Vol.10. No.29. P.2791–2803.
• Ngwa A.T., Pone D.K. & Mafeni J.M. 2000. Feed selection and dietary preferences of forages by small ruminants grazing natural pasture in the Sahelian zone of Cameroon // Animal Feed Science and Technology. Vol.88. P.253–266.
• Omphile U.J., Aganga A.A. & Malamba B. 2005. Diet and forage preference of communally grazed range goats in an Acacia bush savannah in southeast Botswana // Journal of Biological Sciences. Vol.5. No.6. P.690–693.
• O’Reagain P.J. & Mentis M.T. 1989. Seasonal changes in the quality of diet selected by cattle grazing the Natal Sourveld // Journal of the Grassland Society of Southern Africa. Vol.5. P.48–51.
• Pianka E.R. 1973. The structure of lizard communities // Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics. Vol.4. P.53–74.
• Papachristou T.G. & Nastis A.S. 1993. Diets of goats grazing oak shrublands of varying cover in northern Greece // Journal of Range Management. Vol.46. P.220–226.
• Papachristou T.G., Dziba L.E. & Provenza F.D. 2005. Foraging ecology of goats and sheep on wooded rangelands // Small Ruminant Research. Vol.59. No.2. P.141–156.
• Papanastasis V.P. 1997. Livestock grazing in Mediterranean ecosystems: an historical and policy perspective // Papanastasis V.P. & Peter D. (eds.). Ecological basis of livestock grazing in Mediterranean ecosystems, European commision science, research and development, Proceedings of the International Workshop. Thessaloniki, Greece. P.5–9.
• Pfister J.A. & Malechek J.C. 1986. The voluntary forage intake and nutrition of goats and sheep in the semi-arid tropics of northeastern Brazil // Journal of Animal Science. Vol.63. No.4. P.1078–1086.
• Prins H.H.T. 1992. The pastoral road to extinction: competition between wildlife and traditional pastoralism in East Africa // Environmental Conservation. Vol.19. P.117–123.
• Putman R.J., Culpin S. & Thirgood S.J. 1993. Dietary differences between male and female fallow deer in sympatry and allopatry // Journal of Zoology. Vol.229. No.2. P.267–275.
• Ramirez R.G., Rios E. & Garza J. 1993. Preference indices for forage species grazed by Spanish goats on a semi-arid shrubland // Journal of Applied Animal Research. Vol.3. No.1. P.55–66.
• Schoener T.W. 1971. Theory of feeding strategies // Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics. Vol.2. No.1. P.369–404.
• Schoener T.W. 1983. Field experiments on interspecific competition // The American Naturalist. Vol.122. P.240–285.
• Schwartz C.C. & Ellis J.E. 1981. Feeding ecology and niche separation in some native and domestic ungulates on the shortgrass prairie // Journal of Applied Ecology. Vol.18. No.2. P.343–353.
• Seligman N.G. & Perevolotsky A. 1994. Has intensive grazing by domestic livestock degraded Mediterranean Basin rangelands? // Arianoutsou M. & Groves R.H. (eds.). Plant-animal Interactions in Mediterranean-type Ecosystems. Springer. P.93–103.
• Sellami M. 1999. La Gazelle de Cuvier Gazella cuvieri (Ogilby, 1841) en Algérie. Statut et premiers éléments d
• Shipley L.A. 1999. Grazers and browsers: how digestive morphology affects diet selection // Launchbaugh K.L., Sanders K.D. & Mosley J.C. (eds.). Grazing behavior of livestock and wildlife. Idaho Forest, Wildlife & Range Experiment Station Bulletin. No.70. Moscow, Idaho: University of Idaho. P.20–27.
• Shrestha R., Wegge P. & Koirala R.A. 2005. Summer diets of wild and domestic ungulates in Nepal Himalaya // Journal of Zoology. Vol.266. P.111–119.
• Sih A. & Christensen B. 2001. Optimal diet theory: When does it work, and when and why does it fail? // Animal Behaviour. Vol.61. No.2. P.379–390.
• Soder J.K., Gregorini P., Scaglia G. & Rook A.J. 2009. Dietary selection by domestic grazing ruminants in temperate pastures: current state of knowledge, methodologies and future direction // Rangeland Ecology & Management. Vol.62. No.5. P.389–398.
• Sparks D.R. & Malechek J.C. 1968. Estimating percentage dry weights in diets using a microscope technique // Journal of Range Management. Vol.21. No.4. P.264–265.
• Squires V.R. 1982. Competitive interactions in the dietary preference of kangaroos and sheep, cattle and goats in inland Australia // Journal of Arid Environments. Vol.5. P.337–345.
• Stelfox B. & Hudson R.J. 1986. Body condition of male Thomson
• Stewart D.R.M., Stewart J., 1971. Comparative food preferences of five East African ungulates at different seasons // Watt E. & Duffey A.S. (eds.). The Scientific Management of Animal and Plant Communities for Conservation. Oxford: Blackwell Science Publishing. P.351–366.
• Stewart K.M., Bowyer R.T., Kie J.G., Cimon N.J. & Johnson B.K. 2002. Temporospatial distributions of elk, mule deer, and cattle: resource partitioning and competitive displacement // Journal of Mammalogy. Vol.83. No.1. P.229–244.
• Syed Z. & Khan M.S. 2017. Livestock and wild herbivores in the western Himalaya: competition or co-existence? // Journal of Threatened Taxa. Vol.9. No.4. P.10084–10088.
• Talbi K. 1989. Etude éco-éthologique de la Gazelle du Cuvier (Gazella cuvieri Ogilby, 1841) dans la zone de Djebel El Achch. Wilaya de Saïda. Thèse Magistère, Institut National Agronomique Alger, Algérie. 145 p.
• Talbot L.M. & Talbot M.H. 1962. Food preferences of some East African wild ungulates // East African Agricultural and Forestry Journal. Vol.27. No.3. P.131–138.
• Thirwood J.V. 1981. Man and the Mediterranean Forest. New York: Academic Press. 194 p.
• Van Dyne G.M. & Heady H.F. 1965. Dietary chemical composition of cattle and sheep grazing in common on dry annual range // Journal of Range Management. Vol.18. P.78–86.
• Vavra M. & Sheehy D.P. 1996. Improving elk habitat characteristics with livestock grazing // Rangelands. Vol.18. P.182–185.
• Voeten M.M. 1999. Living with wildlife: coexistence of wildlife and livestock in an East African savanna system // PhD Thesis, Wageningen University, Wageningen, the Netherlands. 168 p.
• Wang L., Wang D., Liu J., Huang Y. & Hodgkinson K.C. 2011. Diet selection variation of a large herbivore in a feeding experiment with increasing species numbers and different plant functional group combinations // Acta Oecologica. Vol.37. No.3. P.263–268.
• Ward A.L. 1970. Stomach content and fecal analysis: methods of forage identification // Range and Wildlife Habitat Evaluation: A Research Symposium, D.C. Washington, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Miscellaneous Publication. No.1147. P.146–158.
• Wiens J.A. 1977. On competition and variable environments // American Scientist. Vol.65. P.590–597.
• Xu W., Xia C., Yang W., Blank D.A., Qiao J. & Liu W. 2012. Seasonal diet of khulan (Equidae) in Northern Xinjiang, China // Italian Journal of Zoology. Vol.79. No.1. P.92–99.
• Yahi N., Benhouhou S., Véla E., De Belair G. & Gharzouli R. 2011. Algeria // Radford E.A., Catullo G. & de Montmollin B. (eds.). Important Plant Areas of the south and east Mediterranean region: Priority Sites for Conservation. Malaga: IUCN. P.27–30.
• Zaime A. & Gautier J.Y. 1989. Comparaison des régimes alimentaires de trois espèces sympatriques de Gerbillidae en milieu saharien au Maroc // Revue d